hit counter

« England defeat New Zealand and seal the series | Main | New Zealand vs England - England SHIT/GOOD™ series ratings »

New Zealand vs England - Series Player Ratings: New Zealand

80366144_2

Okay, it wasn't the best cricket we've ever seen, but it was competitive and unpredictable and, at the end (as our picture shows) poignant. The Trumpet awards the series an 8, but cross the jump for the New Zealand player ratings.

Jamie How 6 - A vital 92 on the first day of the series set up the Kiwis' extraordinary demolition of England in the First Test. Thereafter looked slightly out of his depth.

Matthew Bell 3 - Scores heavily in the domestic game, but seems paralysed by nerves in the international spotlight. Should sign up to a TV dance competition immediately.

Stephen Fleming 7 - Looks fantastic, a God amongst mortals, but still the match-turning knocks elude him. For a man unfulfilled as a batsman, it is deeply depressing to hear of his retirement at 34. He should speak to Graham Gooch.

Matthew Sinclair 1 - Not good enough.

Ross Taylor 8 - Made a dazzling 120 to set up the win in Hamilton, thereafter dazzled intermittently. Easy to forget that he has played just five Tests. If Vettori's bowling deteriorates further, expect whispers of captaincy.

Jacob Oram 6 - A batting all-rounder who played as a bowler who bats. Still doesn't convince at Test level - more of a Lancashire League pro playing a bit above his comfort level.

Brendon McCullum 5 - Gilchrist-lite. Slightly too pleased with himself, poor shot selection was his undoing too often. Keeping was showy rather than safe.

Daniel Vettori 6 - A bowling all rounder who played as a batsman who bowls. Captained beautifully at Hamilton, but was less convincing in the two defeats. His lack of penetration with the ball must be worrying him.

Kyle Mills 7 - Honest trier whose decapitation of the England order in the second innings at Hamilton sealed the win.

Jeetan Patel 7 - Outbowled his captain and brought energy and commitment to the field.

Chris Martin 6 - Took wickets regularly, but never looked like a running through a side. Too one-dimensional to trouble international batsmen. Showed real guts to allow Southee's cameo after a clout on the head.

Tim Southee 8 - Bowled a superb opening spell at Napier, then played an Astlesque innings when the game was up. Beautiful action, tremendous hand-eye coordination, wonderful temperament, big, strong boy - what more can one ask of a teenage cricketer?

Mark Gillespie and Grant Elliot 1 - Not Test cricketers on this evidence.

[The Tooting Trumpet] [Image: Getty]

 

March 26, 2008 in England in New Zealand 2007-08, General musings, New Zealand cricket, News Pavilion, Stats and facts | Permalink | StumbleUpon Toolbar Stumble It!

Comments

Hip-Hop player ratings:

Cook - WACK
Vaughan - WACK
Strauss - SICK
Pietersen - SICK
Bell - WACK
Collingwood - SICK
Ambrose - SICK
Broad - SICK
Sidebottom - SICK
Anderson - WACK
Panesar - SICK
Hoggard - WACK
Harmison - WACK

Posted by: Snooker Loopy | 26 Mar 2008 12:43:50

Doggie comms:
Vaughan - worn and thin and gaunt - but such men are dangerous - could be captain again
Cook - cold larder and batter apprentice to chef mike -captain in wanting
Strauss - tuned occassionally - could be captain of the seconds - fragile but can perform
Pietersen - skunk days - could be vice captain of something, say media?
Bell - for whom the ball tells - could be captain next century - appealing at times but seems too often wrung out
Collingwood - red wobbler - should be captain - suggests possibilities if given a chance
Ambrose - lost honey homeboy - never be captain - being successor to nixon is not all the peanuts its cracked up to be
Broad - not - but filling - could be vice captain - son of the great brushstroke
Sidebottom - frontal presentation rare and getting bits in order finally - could be captain in the vein of Oldbotham (or was he Topbotham?)
Anderson - needs more coaching from Ander - never be captain of anything
Panesar - almost the daughter of Asclepius but needs bits re-arranged - could be captain but needs to smile more
Hoggard - bringing home the limelight not - captain of the Flintoff wannabees and heading that way
Harmison - been Trescothicked by the Kingdom media - should be captain for 2009 Ashes

Posted by: doctorshoot | 26 Mar 2008 22:20:15

The comments to this entry are closed.